Is using all Gothic caps together an acceptable practice for good calligraphers?

Using all Gothic caps together is not considered an acceptable practice for good calligraphers primarily because it can lead to a lack of visual balance and harmony in the lettering. In traditional calligraphy, especially with Gothic scripts, the use of uppercase letters is typically complemented by lowercase letters or varied letter sizes to create a more aesthetically pleasing composition.

When all letters are in caps, it often results in a block-like appearance that can overwhelm the viewer and detract from the overall design and readability of the text. Good calligraphy involves a careful consideration of letterforms, spacing, and the relationship between characters, which can be compromised when using all caps in Gothic style. Instead, a mix of upper and lower case or strategic use of capitals within a word or phrase can enhance the elegance and flow of the calligraphy. This approach respects the traditions and conventions of the art form, allowing for a more skillful and thoughtful presentation.